Skip to main content

Featured four-star hotel destinations

Destination inspiration for your trip – find a four-star hotel

The best four-star hotels in Bay of Islands

Check out our pick of great four-star hotels in Bay of Islands

Filter by:


Review score

Superb: 9+ Very good: 8+ Good: 7+ Pleasant: 6+
Our top picks Lowest price first Star rating and price Top reviewed

See the latest prices and deals by choosing your dates.

Avalon, in a tranquil garden setting, offers self-catering cottages with free Wi-Fi and balconies overlooking the valley and the Puketotora River. It features a chemical-free outdoor swimming pool and spa facilities. Beautiful setting and very comfortable accommodation. Loved the spa and the natural pool. The bbq area was also really lovely. Our cottage was well equipped and we really enjoyed our stay.

Show more Show less
9.2
Superb
1,223 reviews
Price from
US$98
per night

Set in Paihia and only 1.2 km from Te Ti Bay Beach, Allegra House offers accommodation with sea views, free WiFi and free private parking. With garden views, this accommodation provides a balcony. This 4-star bed and breakfast offers private entrance. Heinz & Brita were the most gracious hosts. The room had everything we needed for our stay, very comfortable, and the view from the balcony was stunning! The Allegra House was a close walk to everything Paihia, and they have a cute little shortcut path down the hill. The breakfast & homemade bread was delicious ~ so much to choose from to start your day. We would definitely come back to Paihia & stay at the Allegra House again.

Show more Show less
9.8
Exceptional
162 reviews
Price from
US$187
per night

Situated in Kerikeri, 24 km from Opua Forest, Stone Store Lodge has a garden, parking on-site and rooms with free WiFi access. Boasting a shared kitchen, this property also provides guests with a sun terrace. The property offers soundproof units and is set 200 metres from Kemp House and Stone Store. So much extra effort by owner - was amazing as it was my brother in law 60th birthday & we didn’t want to go out so we made a home cooked meal - he’s. Vegetarian The fireplace 😍 the use of kitchen & the lounge was really a treat after a long drive from Rotorua

Show more Show less
9
Superb
195 reviews
Price from
US$121
per night

Abri Apartments in Paihia provides adults-only accommodation with a garden and barbecue facilities. This property offers access to a balcony, free private parking and free WiFi. When staying at the apartment, guests can use private entrance. Set up above the town and away from traffic.noise, the apartment has a lovely view across the bay. The apartment is spacious, comfortably furnished, and well equipped. The host is friendly and helpful.

Show more Show less
9.5
Exceptional
150 reviews
Price from
US$135
per night

Surrounded by lovely gardens and situated on the waterfront, Hananui Lodge and Apartments features accommodation with free WiFi, a private balcony or patio and an LCD TV. Guests enjoy a free use of kayaks. Fantastic central location and next to the water. Fabulous big bed & spacious room, exceptionally clean, with verandah to watch the world go by and see the sun go down. Right over the road, big store selling everything you might need.

Show more Show less
9.2
Superb
565 reviews
Price from
US$122
per night

The property offers air-conditioned deluxe king studios, one and two-bedroom apartments and an executive suite. The studios, one and two-bedroom apartments have kitchenette facilities, unlimited free WiFi, satellite TV and the use of the barbecue area with outdoor seating. The apartments on the upper level open onto a communal balcony offering lovely sea views. Each unit has outdoor seating to enjoy the sunrise or sunset. The host was so friendly and helpful. She gave us great tips about places to eat. The rooms were very well set up and spacious. Fresh milk for cups of tea:) Delicious biscuits.

Show more Show less
9.2
Superb
188 reviews
Price from
US$106
per night

Set in a peaceful neighbourhood, ASURE Admirals View Motel offers self-contained accommodation with scenic sea views in most rooms. Featuring a library, it offers Wi-Fi, bike rental and parking for free. The facilities are new, the staff is friendly and nice.

Show more Show less
9
Superb
308 reviews
Price from
US$102
per night

A welcoming glass of wine or a beer and other treats await the guests. All accommodation features a flat-screen TV. A microwave, a refrigerator and tea/coffee making facilities are standard in all rooms. Your modern bathroom includes a shower, hairdryer and free toiletries. There is parking for cars and boats. Wow, this has been a great experience! The Colonial House Motel is a lovely place, a beautiful garden, nice rooms, filled with hospitality. Owner Mark personally showed us our room, making us feel welcome from the very first second on. The room is equipped with everything an (overseas) tourist needs. In our room there was even a travel adapter power plug. Laundry service is available complete with clothes airers. When we arrived, Mark was working in the garden. Upon arrival he said we came on a good time: time also for a short break from gardening. This was another way we felt very welcome. The owners not just own this place, they live it. They live hospitality. Thanks very much, Mark and Paula. I would highly recommend the Colonial House Motel for anyone travelling in the Kerikeri and Bay of Islands area.

Show more Show less
9
Superb
549 reviews
Price from
US$119
per night

Edgewater Palms Apartments is located opposite Paihia's main beach and offers an infinity lap pool set amongst landscaped tropical grounds. Guests enjoy free unlimited WiFi.

All rooms at Edgewater Paihia have views toward the ocean. Each apartment includes a spacious kitchen, laundry facilities and an en suite bathroom with under-floor heating. Amazing location in front of beach and close walk to activities shops and restaurants. Friendly staff and beautiful apartment. Clean, great views , comfortable and spacious. Perfect to get your boats or visit treaty grounds.

Show more Show less
9.1
Superb
613 reviews
Price from
US$209
per night

Located in Kerikeri, this property is only 200 metres from the town centre. Guests have access to free WiFi and free private parking.

All rooms at Stay Kerikeri boast a low-rise retro architecture style. The rooms are large, fully self-contained and are serviced daily by housekeeping. Facilities include flat-screen satellite TV, hairdryers, iron and ironing board. We loved everything about Stay Kerikeri! Bill and Paula were so warm and welcoming. The gardens and grounds are beautiful. Our unit was spotless and had everything we needed. The location is perfect for exploring the town of Kerikeri and the Bay of Islands area.

Show more Show less
9.5
Exceptional
299 reviews
Price from
US$142
per night

Most booked four-star hotels in Bay of Islands this month

FAQs about four-star hotels in Bay of Islands

Four-Star Hotels that guests love in Bay of Islands